The Marin County District Attorney’s office was scheduled to hold a pretrial hearing Monday, Dec. 8, on charges brought by the San Francisco Archdiocese of felony vandalism against five Native American Activists who tore down a statue of Junipero Serra that stood in front of the Mission San Rafael on Oct. 12—Indigenous Peoples’ Day.
The pretrial or arraignment hearing is a standard part of the court process where the judge informs defendants on the charges being brought against them, their constitutional rights and typically sets a date for an actual hearing. The pretrial was initially scheduled and held via ZOOM video conference, but the judge presiding over the case pushed the pre trial date to Friday Dec. 11.
The Native American Community is calling the activists being charged the #IndigenousPeoples5; or the “IP 5” and demanding all charges be dropped against the five indigenous women. Charged with felony vandalism are Oakland residents Ines Shiam Gardilcic, 40, and Victoria Eva Montanopena, 29; Melissa Aguilar, 36, of Novato; Marjorie Nadeska Delgadillo, 36, of San Rafael, and Moira Cribben Van de Walker, 25 of San Anselmo.
In a virtual press conference held by Communities United for Restorative Justice (CURYJ), Indigenous spiritual leaders and faith-based leaders made statements of support of the IP 5.
George Galvis, Executive Director of CURYJ, asserts that the Catholic Church positions itself as a leader in restorative justice but is out of step with the national movement to remove symbols of hate. “We are not apologetic about the removal of the statue, in fact, I think there is an opportunity for the Catholic Church and the Archdioceses to start making amends and atone for some of the harm they have caused to the indigenous peoples of California and across Indian Country beginning with the California Mission System,” Galvis said. “Those were indigenous slave plantations; we can’t continue to sweep this history under the rug. I think an apology from the Catholic Church when they charge indigenous women with felony vandalism and criminalize them at a time when we know the Catholic Church and Catholic Charities get millions of dollars in grant funding to do restorative justice in the bay area. It is absolutely hypocritical.”
Morning Star Gali, Executive Director of Restoring Justice for Indigenous Peoples and enrolled member of Ajumawi Band of Pit River Tribe said, “I support all tearing down of monuments to colonialism to genocide and white supremacy. Junipero Serra was a missionary of genocide. In the 1700s he imposed Christian missions through so-called California and captured, enslaved, and brutally assimilated California Indigenous Peoples.”
Gali then read a written statement from Andrea Carmen of the International Indian Treaty Council. The following is an excerpt from that written statement:
‘The brutal history of the colonization of California, including through the establishment of the missions which resulted in forced relocation, enslavement, violence and forced conversion of Indigenous Peoples, has not been fully told. Indigenous and non-Indigenous children are taught half-truths in public schools about the history of California to this day, including the actions and role of Father Junipero Serra. This is not a disparagement of anyone else’s religion. But we also have a right to live in dignity, free from racism and the continued trauma of misstated versions of history.’